Joe Spinell as Willi Cicci, slick Corleone mob family “button man”
New York City, August 1955
Film: The Godfather
Release Date: March 15, 1972
Director: Francis Ford Coppola
Costume Designer: Anna Hill Johnstone
When the boss says push the button on a guy, I push the button, see, Senator?
Today’s #MafiaMonday post focuses on one of the more celebrated minor characters of The Godfather, Corleone family enforcer Willi Cicci, who stands out with his slick sense of style and laidback demeanor. Imagine if Dean Martin had grown a mustache and joined the mob… that’s Willi Cicci for ya.
Cicci best gets the opportunity to explain his short yet memorable role in The Godfather when testifying in front of a Senate committee in the film’s sequel. When we first meet him in The Godfather, Cicci is getting a shave in a hotel barbershop with an unflappable, can’t-be-bothered attitude that may trick first-time viewers into thinking he is one of the many targets that Michael Corleone has marked for death on this transformative day for the New York Mafia.
Alas, Willi rises from his completed shave, enjoys a leisurely smoke in the hotel stairwell, and – upon seeing Don Cuneo (Rudy Bond) step into the revolving door in his summer white dinner jacket – blocks the door and shoots the trapped don to death.
Four years later, the fractured Corleone family is the subject of a Senate investigation. Willi Cicci, who defended himself ably after he and his boss Frankie Pentangeli were trapped in a bar, becomes a government informant for an enlightening and entertaining testimony reportedly inspired by real-life mob turncoats Joe Valachi and Joseph “The Animal” Barboza, the latter of which shares more than a passing resemblance to the swarthy Willi Cicci.
What’d He Wear?
Unlike his boss, Willi Cicci is one guy who is fine with dressing the part of the typical flashy mobster. We are introduced to Willi toward the end of The Godfather as the nonchalant hitman is settling in for a shave in a hotel barbershop.
Willi wears a gray sportcoat in what appears to be Donegal tweed with white flecks in the suiting consistent with that material. The ventless single-breasted jacket has notch lapels that roll to a low two-button stance that fastens at his waist. The shoulders are padded with roped sleeveheads, and a hint of a brown pocket square pokes out of the welted breast pocket. The jacket has patch pockets on the hips.
The jacket may earn the approval of discerning sartorial eyes, but Willi’s colorful choice of a shirt and tie may have said eyes rolling or turning away in disapproval. He wears a burnt orange shirt with a semi-spread collar, flapped breast pocket, and squared double (French) cuffs worn with a set of round gold links.
Willie’s silk tie is broadly striped in purple, silver, and gold in the classic American “downhill” stripe direction, crossing from the right shoulder down to the left hip.
Contrasting with his flashy upper half, Willi keeps things subdued below the belt with a pair of solid black trousers with turn-ups (cuffs), black leather cap-toe derby shoes, and black socks.
For all of his flash, Willi wears a surprisingly conservative amount of jewelry for a gangster. He wears a gold ring with a dark stone on the third finger – rather than the pinky – of his left hand, and he sports a gold wristwatch with a round case and gold dial on a black textured leather strap.
The next time we see Cicci, he is dressed down in a brown suede jacket, an open-neck shirt, and a pair of black sunglasses when informing Sal Tessio about a change of plans.
How to Get the Look
Subtlety and color coordination aren’t exactly in Willi Cicci’s sartorial lexicon, as the slick hitman dresses with colorful pizzazz when embarking on his murderous deeds on behalf of the Corleone crime family.
- Gray fleck Donegal tweed single-breasted 2-button sportcoat with notch lapels, welted breast pocket, patch hip pockets, and ventless back
- Burnt orange shirt with semi-spread collar, flapped pocket, and squared double/French cuffs
- Gold round cuff links
- Purple, silver, and gold widely “downhill”-striped silk tie
- Black trousers with turn-ups/cuffs
- Black leather cap-toe derby shoes
- Black socks
- Gold round-case wristwatch with gold dial on textured black leather strap
- Gold ring with dark stone
Willi Cicci uses a classic M1911A1 semi-automatic pistol as his weapon of choice for murdering Don Cuneo.
Unlike some productions of the era that swapped in the cosmetically similar Star Model B pistol for the ease of operating 9mm blank ammunition, Cicci’s handgun appears to be a traditional 1911 chambered for .45 ACP, based on the bore size and the lack of the Star’s brass external extractor on the right side of the slide.
Do Yourself a Favor and…
Willi Cicci was reportedly meant to be a more central character in The Godfather Part III, but Joe Spinell died after a tragic accident in his Queens apartment in January 1989 and his character was written out of the final script.
Cicci’s story and role is slightly expanded in the video game, The Godfather, where his first name is alternately spelled “Willie” and he is depicted as a long-time member of the Corleone crime family dating back to 1946. The game dresses Cicci in a gray suit, orange shirt, and striped tie clearly inspired by this colorful ensemble in The Godfather, though it tops him off with a gray fedora.